2021 - Evelyn Gill
2019 - Mike O'Neill
2018 - Joe Russo
2017 - Glenn Crooks, Kevin Dearman, Krissy Turner
2016 - John Harkes2015 - Tony Meola
2014 - Raul Donoso
2013 - Gene Chyzowyck, Mark Geiger, Tab Ramos, Spencer Rockman
2012 - Bob Rostron, Bob Turner
2011 - Tobin Heath, Carli Lloyd, Jill Loyden, Christie Pearce Rampone
2010 - Peter Elz, Jerry Jerome
2009 - Al Sinclair, Art Vespignani
2008 - Jerry Hafycz, Barry Towbin
2007 - Glenn Myernick, Bobby Smith
2006 - Bob Bair
2005 - Flo Egan, Lance Meehan
2004 - Alan Jeffers, Joseph Robb
2003 - Tom Byrne, Earl Fielder, Guido Guazzoni
2002 - Tim Howard, Heather O'Reilly
2001 - Dave Jenkins, Joseph Lovero
2000 - John Benn, Andrew W. Patten
1999 - Al Cowell, Phyllis Lucariello, Raymond Popdan
1998 - Ben Curri, Frank Giuliano, Audun Gythfeldt
1997 - Edward Eimer, Wesley LaBar
1996 - Dan Bigley, Liesel Krehan
1995 - Leonard Block, Joseph Carratura
1994 - Ronald Kintner, Walter Park Sr., Walter "Buzz" Seaman, Brian Wratten
1993 - Thomas Gallagher, Thomas J. Kain III, Paul Mott Jr., Robert Reichenbach, Jeanine Willis
1992 - Robert Burkhard, John Callaghan, Theresa Henn, Bob McNulty, Charles Stillitano, Sr.
1991 - Harry Baldwin, John Conover, Roman Nahirniak, Albert Wilson
1990 - Jim Brackenridge, Albert Caseiro, Tony Cullen, Arbey Hudson, Tom Mara
1989 - Miller Bugliari, Rudy Burkhard, Otto Haus, Charles Kellogg, Frank Kelly, Edward Kennedy, Lori Lange, Manfred Schellscheidt